Skip to content

IN EGYPT AS ELSEWHERE: POLITICAL ISLAM IS NOT THE SOLUTION – IT IS THE PROBLEM

September 5, 2012

Muslim Brotherhood poster in 2011, “Islam is the solution; together for reform; Muslim Ikhwan carry goodness to all peoples”.[1]

Islam is the solution”, is the Islamists’ slogan: by this they mean Islam will save Egypt from all its social, economic and political problems. Of course that is nonsense – Islam, and by Islam I mean political Islam, is not the solution, but part, a huge part, of the problem. But not too many people in Egypt have sufficient courage or intellectual honesty to say that.

Those who believe political Islam is not the solution are either terrorised into muttering what they don’t believe, making them hypocrites, or beating round the bush by criticising the Islamist experiments in our modern age, whether in Iran, Saudi, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Somalia or Sudan, but immediately adding the caveat: “The problem is not in Islam; the problem is in those who implement Islam [wrongly]”, thereby assisting in the repetition of the failed, horrible previous Islamist experiments in the hope of getting it right.

One can understand to some extent the cowardice and dishonesty of these peoples: the Islamists are out there to terrorise them, and can condemn them easily as renegades (mortad’deen), which is punishable by death in Islam.[2] Cowardice and dishonesty in Egypt saves one’s life; however, it will not save Egypt from destruction: from the Islamists’ dictatorship, oppression of all including women, restriction of human rights and fundamental freedoms, failed economy, terrorism, unnecessary wars, ostracisation, polarisation, divisions, civil wars, and the risking of Egypt’s territorial integrity.

The future of Egypt cannot be expected to be different from that of its southern neighbour Sudan if it implemented Sharia – Sharia is the same whether in Egypt or Sudan, and will bring about with it the same outcomes wherever it is implemented.

No, Islam is not the solution;[3] Islam is the problem. If Egyptians don’t come to that conclusion early, Egypt will be lost.

This writer does not do cowardice or intellectual dishonesty; he does not get intimidated, and he does not mince his words – but he is not anti-Islam, by which I mean non-political Islam, and he is not anti-Muslims: he has no quarrel whatsoever with the Muslims’ private beliefs; he believes that there are good Muslims as there are bad Christians; and he trusts that the Just Almighty accepts all good people whatever religious or non-religious background they come from. But he stands firm on this believe: that political Islam is evil, and that the Islamists are the number one threat to Egypt’s democracy, progress and national unity.


[2] The penalty of apostasy in Islam is included in Sunna, i.e. the traditions of Prophet Muhammad.

[3] Again, the writer talks about political Islam here. He does not get involved in discussion of the non-political aspects of Islam. Some may regard criticism of Islam, political Islam, as disrespect – our answer is: if you want to rule us by your religion, you must accept its criticism.

About these ads
4 Comments leave one →
  1. JKL permalink
    September 5, 2012 5:18 pm

    Dear Dioscorus
    You are the voice of reason.
    An excellent post. Political Islam has always been the problem, right from the time of the Ummayads.
    Ironically, over the course of its 1400 years, most political rulers in Muslim governed lands have always viewed Muslim religious leaders with suspicion because Islam never went through the process of knowing its political limits ( as The Church did in Europe through the Renaissance, the Reformation and finally the Enlightenment).
    Political Islam will fail because it never has any solutions other tha ln fear and coercion, like any religion that decides to rule.
    Let the Muslim Egyptians know what Devil they did a pact with for their soul. They will soon find out that they’ve been robbed of their soul, their vote and their freedom.
    Best.
    JKL

    • Dioscorus Boles permalink*
      September 5, 2012 6:45 pm

      Thank you, JKL. Really appreciate it. Dioscorus

  2. September 6, 2012 4:00 pm

    Great Post Dioscorus.
    I took the liberty to repost your post on my blog wirth due credit.

    • Dioscorus Boles permalink*
      September 6, 2012 4:52 pm

      Thanks, Will. You are always welcome.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 3,943 other followers

%d bloggers like this: